Unearthing
history from the depth of the sea is an area not quite in currency in
India. In a pioneering effort the Indian Navy and the Archaeological
Survey of India organised an international seminar on maritime archaeology
in New Delhi to study maritime history through inter-disciplinary
approach.
Purely academic in nature, the
two-day seminar harped on ancient sea-faring traditions and their
influence on activities and development of the region. The theme of the
seminar was- "A marine archaeological perspective of the Indian
Ocean-A gateway to the continents"
One of the most interesting
presentations was that of Prof John Carswell who spoke on the Arab
sea-faring traditions. According to him, the discovery of the monsoons and
the increase in trade between India and Mediterranean played a major role
in the development of maritime activity in the Indian Ocean. The export of
Chinese porcelain to the Islamic world opened up another fascinating world
of study with India as the pivot as it was between East and West.
Rear Adm KR Menon (Retd) pointed out
that interest in history was generally related to the big battles fought
on land. In that case, he remarked that the Battle of Plassey or land
settlement of Bengal are more familiar than the Battle of Nagapattanam
where not a single Indian ship had participated! His presentation brought
out the facets of Indian maritime technological skills. One interesting
approach in his study was the socio-religious factors that influenced
society to be biased against those who took the sea for a calling.
Prof Ranabir Chakravarti studied the
period from 400AD to 1300AD, a less explored area in Indian maritime
trade. His source were epigraphic materials ranging from Arabian and
Persian texts, indigenous literature, Chinese impressions of Indian
products and ports and the Jewish business letters of Indian traders or musafiran-ul-Hind
of eleventh and twelfth centuries. Trade being the main concern, the
study shows that there was little religious animosity between the various
merchants. It was also observed that political powers in India, Islamic
world, Southeast Asia and in China maintained distinct interests in this
trade and encouraged overseas commerce.
Dr Malhao Periera, an ex-captain
from the Portuguese Navy with his practical seafaring knowledge showed how
the stellar compass was accurately used in navigating both in the Indian
Ocean and the Pacific Ocean. His personal interpretation of the stars and
compass was interesting too. In another discourse Erich Reith spoke on the
traditional boat and ships of India through the ethnographical studies of
Admiral Paris (1806-1893) a three-time circumnavigator and ethnographer.
Dr RS Bisht, a Director with ASI highlighted the indigenous ship building
traditions and maritime skills of the proto-historic period. The British
strategic vision of the Indian Ocean from 1857-1947 was one emanating from
imperial and commercial interests. Prof Andrew Lambert brought out the
technological support to maritime practices in the post-industrial
revolution era while Rear Admiral Joseph J Krol from the US Navy presented
a comparative study of the Indian and Pacific Oceans in world maritime
history. A report on archaeological investigation of the wreck of Princes
Royal off Bangaram islands was presented by Cmde AK Patnaik and Mr A
Tripathi.
However, the cultural interfaces
perhaps remains to be studied through the maritime traditions. Throughout
the western coast of India there are strong Islamic influences on
architecture as well as culture. But didn’t the sea trade between
far-east and China through India have any cultural influence? The entire
dark history of trading men as "slaves" from Africa has given
birth to folklores and songs that bear testimony to the times. Can we have
more lighthouses please?
-Sudipta Biswas