It was the practice of the
Europeans to reproduce, as far as possible, in their settlements and
colonies abroad the typical social features of their national lives. The
Portuguese brought the wine restaurant, the French set up the cafe
stretching often to the pavement and the British introduced social clubs
in India.
The British social culture, as
prevalent in their homes and during formal occasions, sports and
entertainment of the 18th Century crystalised around their clubs in India
in the 19th Century and survived till the end of the Raj. The club which
was a singularly male rendezvous in Britain was suitably modified for
India and was perhaps more British than the most sophisticated British
institutions. Most of the British clubs in India specialised in specific
games or sports but were not exclusively or primarily "playing
club". A blend of sports and social activities was a feature of most
of their clubs, particularly smaller military stations. One had to belong
to a club before one could play a game. It was considered obligatory to
belong to a club even if one could not go there regularly due to
constraints of service conditions. Yet there were many who regarded a
visit to the club every evening a part of their duty. Getting together for
games and exercise, and more importantly, for gossip and talks was an
essential part of British lifestyle in India.
The club was also a social centre
for civil and military personnel. It had a special appeal to a large
number of British officers in India who were by force of circumstances
separated from their wives and families for long periods. Bound by common
fortunes in an alien country and because of their distrust and attitude
towards the locals, they naturally leaned on one another for survival.
These clubs were a compensation that alleviated the pain of loneliness and
helped solve through relaxed conversation many a knotty problem,
particularly of bachelors and separated officers who had a distaste for
housekeeping.
Membership to British clubs in
pre-Independence India was decided almost wholly by occupation and in big
cities, discrimination by status was a rigid practice. In smaller towns it
was relaxed in certain clubs for a variety of reasons but mainly for
financial.
Even if one did not feel like
becoming a member of such clubs, it was unwise not to be one, if one
could. "If you didn't belong to a club, you were an outcaste"
said General Savory who later became the Adjutant General in Army
Headquarters in New Delhi. "Some people, however, refused to accept
all such social norms and refused to belong to any club. Intellectuals,
for example, would rather spend their evenings in study. Club going to
them was a waste of time. Either you were a rebel or rather a courageous
rebel who didn’t belong to a club or else you were a social outcaste who
wanted to belong to a club but couldn't get in", he added. "The
issue of Indian membership to British clubs almost split the
Europeans", General Savory maintained, "one of the greatest
mistakes the British ever made was to frown upon Indians becoming members
to their clubs. Some clubs would not allow Indians to be members, as it
was laid down in their club constitution. When one considers that it was
not every Englishman who came to India, who came out of the top drawer,
and there were in India some of the most highly bred, cultivated and
educated men in the world, to keep them out and allow the Englishmen in
was nonsense."
The controversy over Indian
membership centred around colour-bar. It began towards the end of the
first World War and continued well into the second World War. Another
objection was that even if Indians were allowed to join the British clubs,
their female folks would stay away because of purdah and even if
they would come they would not mix with club members without a veil. The
British could not accept this.
The Indianisation of both the civil
and military services made it even more difficult for most of the British
clubs to preserve their exclusiveness. Two well-known examples are the
Wellingdon Club of Bombay and the Calcutta Club. In some cities, mixed
clubs attempted to by-pass this problem. Elsewhere, a head-on clash became
inevitable and reached a crisis point during the second World War. The
President of the Madras Club observed, "we had admitted all European
officers as temporary members but the General Commanding, Madras District
said that he would not allow European officers to become members unless it
was agreed to allow Indian officers also''. The commercial elements
out-voted the officials by a very small majority and it was decided to
still refuse to admit Indians as members. The result was that the European
offices were also not admitted under the order of the General. Other
attempts to break the bar were, however, more successful. General Savory
recalls, "I had an officer in my Regiment who had been a cadet at the
Indian Military Academy under me. I put him up for the club and they
turned him down. I put the club out of bounds to all my officers from that
minute. Eventually, this officer was allowed to become a member of the
club".
Games, particularly tennis, golf,
cricket and riding, especially where a cavalry unit was located, were very
popular. Most clubs had billiard and bridge rooms and usually a very good
library, well-stocked with newspapers and magazines from England. Mornings
were exclusively for the ladies and men could attend clubs only on Sunday
mornings. On almost any evening, social life started with drinks at the
bar. People talked about happenings of the day, Shikar and quite a
lot of "shop". Politics were not discussed particularly if
Indians were present. The ladies talked about servants, children, shopping
and general gossip. Gossip of the most personal kind was, however, kept
for their intimate little dinner parties among a group of close friends.
On certain evenings, there was music usually provided by one of the
military bands and on Saturday nights there was dancing. Christmas and New
Year evenings had special programme for children and for late night
dancing.
The expression Koi Hai (is
anybody there?) is believed to have originated in such clubs, when British
members had to call for the butler. It came to be used in Officers' Messes
and even in bungalows for calling a servant. Initially, the British
members of clubs were not in favour of engaging and allowing Indian
butlers, with a few exceptions as a special case, to their clubs. The
resistance gradually softened and Indian servants became the mainstay of
club service.
After Independence, the void in
clubs created by the departure of the British was filled with great
enthusiasm by civil and military officers. The bar and Sunday luncheons
became quite popular and on Saturday evenings the dance floors were
packed. The initial enthusiasm by officers gradually subsided and initial
interest in these clubs of Indian officers and their invitees veered to
sports and games, both indoor and outdoor. The nouveau riche, who
began to monopolise these clubs for their new-found social life,
patronised the bar with their associates. They preferred entertaining a
guest or a friend in a club and the old Indian practice of entertaining at
home gradually became a rare occasion.
Maj Gen Chand N Das (Retd)